Which Health Sharing Plan Is Right for You?
It depends on what matters most to you. If cost is king, CHM starts at $115/month. If you want broad coverage with no faith requirement, Zion HealthShare runs $185–$268/month. Christian families tend to gravitate toward Medi-Share ($227–$405/month) for its 30-year track record. There's no single "best" — the right plan depends on your health, budget, and beliefs.
Zion HealthShare (4.8/5 rating) offers broadest coverage at $185-$268/month with no faith requirement. CHM is cheapest at $115/month but requires Christian faith. Medi-Share (4.5/5) serves 400,000+ members with 30+ year track record at $227-$405/month.
Every health sharing plan serves different priorities. Zion HealthShare (4.8/5) costs $185-$268/month with no faith requirement, unlimited sharing, and a Cigna PPO network with 950,000+ providers. Medi-Share (4.5/5, $227-$405/month) offers a Christian community with 400,000+ members and 30+ years of history. CHM starts at $115/month for budget-conscious individuals. Compare all 7 plans below to find your match.
Last updated: February 2026 | All pricing verified from official plan websites
Plans by Priority
| Lowest Cost | CHM ($115/mo individual) |
| Broadest Coverage | Zion HealthShare (4.8/5, $185-$268/mo) |
| Christian Community | Medi-Share (4.5/5, $681-$1,215/mo family) |
| No Faith Requirement | Zion HealthShare, Sedera, CrowdHealth, Presidio |
| No Pre-Existing Wait | Zion HealthShare, CrowdHealth |
| Plans Reviewed | 0 plans |
Why Zion HealthShare Has the Highest Rating
Zion HealthShare receives a 4.8/5 rating due to its combination of broad coverage, competitive pricing, and no faith requirement. It's one of the few health sharing plans that covers pre-existing conditions from day one with no waiting period. Its Cigna PPO network provides access to 950,000+ providers with negotiated rates, reducing out-of-pocket costs. Coverage includes telehealth, prescriptions, maternity, mental health, preventive care, emergency, and surgery.
At $185-$268/month for individuals, Zion costs more than CHM ($115/month starting) but includes additional coverage like prescriptions, mental health, telehealth, and no pre-existing waiting period. Zion is also HSA-compatible, providing tax benefits that can reduce the effective cost. Founded in 2017, it's newer than CHM (1981) or Medi-Share (1992) but has grown to 50,000+ members. Whether the extra cost is worth it depends on your health needs and budget.
How Do All Plans Compare?
| Rank | Plan | Rating | Individual/mo | Faith Req. | Sharing Cap | Pre-Existing Wait |
|---|
Which Plan Is Best for Families?
For Christian families, Medi-Share offers the most established family coverage with 400,000+ members and a 30+ year track record. Family plans cost $681-$1,215/month depending on the IUA level. Medi-Share covers maternity, telehealth, preventive care, emergency, and surgery. It requires a Christian statement of faith but not church attendance.
For families without faith preferences, Zion HealthShare provides family plans at $555-$804/month with broader coverage than Medi-Share — including prescriptions and mental health. Zion also has no pre-existing condition waiting period, which matters for families with children who may have existing health needs. CHM offers the cheapest family option at $345-$792/month but requires strict Christian faith and church attendance, and does not cover telehealth, prescriptions, or mental health.
Which Plan Is Best for Self-Employed Individuals?
Self-employed individuals benefit most from Zion HealthShare due to its HSA compatibility and no faith requirement. Contributing to an HSA while on a Zion plan provides a triple tax benefit: tax-deductible contributions, tax-free growth, and tax-free withdrawals for medical expenses. At $185-$268/month, it saves $2,000- $5,000/year compared to unsubsidized ACA marketplace plans.
CrowdHealth is another strong option for healthy self-employed people at approximately $140/month average. It offers month-to-month flexibility with no contracts and strong bill negotiation services (30-60% discounts on planned procedures). However, CrowdHealth limits pre-existing condition sharing for the first two years, making it less suitable for anyone with existing health conditions.
The Bottom Line
Zion HealthShare is the best health sharing plan for most people in 2026. It offers the broadest coverage, no faith requirement, unlimited sharing, HSA compatibility, and no pre-existing condition waiting period — all at $185-$268/month for individuals. The only reason to choose a different plan is if you want the lowest possible cost (CHM at $115/month), prefer a faith-based community (Medi-Share or Samaritan), or want a crowdfunding model (CrowdHealth).
Not sure which plan fits your situation? Use our free quiz to get a personalized recommendation in 2 minutes, or compare all plans side-by-side.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often do you update these rankings?
Rankings are updated quarterly. All pricing, coverage, and membership data is verified directly from official plan websites. Our rating methodology weighs Cost (30%), Coverage breadth (25%), Member satisfaction (20%), Pre-existing condition policies (15%), and Transparency (10%). The last full review was completed in February 2026.
Is Zion HealthShare good for older adults?
Zion HealthShare accepts members of all ages and does not have age-based pricing tiers beyond its standard range. For adults approaching Medicare eligibility (65+), health sharing can bridge the gap. However, if you have significant pre-existing conditions, compare the cost of Zion with ACA marketplace plans that offer subsidies. Zion's no-waiting-period policy for pre-existing conditions is a significant advantage for older adults.
Can I switch health sharing plans?
Yes. Health sharing plans are month-to-month with most ministries. You can cancel one plan and enroll in another at any time. There is no open enrollment period for health sharing. Note that if you switch plans, any pre-existing condition waiting period will restart with the new plan (except Zion HealthShare, which has no waiting period).
Do you earn commissions from these recommendations?
No. WhichHealthShare does not earn affiliate commissions. Our revenue comes from selling premium tools ($20) that help families model medical scenarios and compare plans side-by-side. This means our recommendations are based solely on which plan best fits your situation, not what makes us money. See our disclosure page for full details on our business model and editorial independence.
What if I need dental and vision coverage?
No health sharing plan includes dental or vision as standard coverage. The only option in our comparison that includes both is Presidio Healthcare ($300-$600/month), which is regulated insurance, not health sharing. For health sharing members, standalone dental and vision plans are available through providers like Delta Dental and VSP for $20-$50/month each.
Find Your Best Plan in 60 Seconds
Answer 6 quick questions and we'll match you with the health sharing plan that fits your budget, health needs, and preferences.
Want a quick comparison guide?
We'll email you a side-by-side breakdown of pricing, coverage, and what real members say about the top plans.
Free guide + 7-day email series. Unsubscribe anytime.