Aetna vs Cigna Dental Savings Plans: Full Comparison for 2026

The offer reviewed here is 1Dental’s Dental Access membership using the Aetna Dental Access network, a separate product from carrier-direct Aetna Vital Savings. Neither it nor Cigna Dental Savings is insurance. The catalog lists 262,000+ Aetna provider locations and about 110,000 Cigna dentists; these are different units and publication dates, so they do not establish which network is larger. Through 1Dental, the listed Aetna individual price is $14.95/mo and family price is $19.95/mo, with a $30 setup fee. Cigna costs $96/year individual or $132/year family, paid annually in full ($8/mo or $11/mo equivalents, not monthly billing). Compare the exact membership terms, first-year fees and your dentist’s participation before choosing.

Aetna Dental Savings

Major insurer's dental discount network with one of the largest provider lists

★★★★☆4.2

From $14.95/mo · 262,000+ provider locations

Cigna Dental Savings

Cigna's discount dental plan with strong PPO network

★★★★☆4.1

$96/year · annual billing · ~110,000 in-network dentists

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureAetna Dental SavingsCigna Dental Savings
Individual/month$14.95/mo + $30 setup✓$96/year ($8/mo equivalent; paid annually)
Family/month$19.95/mo + $30 setup✓$132/year ($11/mo equivalent; paid annually)
Network size✓262,000+ locations~110,000 dentists (different unit/date)
Typical savings15–50%15–40%
Activation timeEstimated 3 business days; confirm with sellerUsually 3 business days; confirm activation
Waiting periodNoneNone
Annual maximumNoneNone
Cleanings & examsIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
FillingsIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
Root canalsIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
ExtractionsIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
Crowns & bridgesIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
DenturesIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
Periodontal (gum) treatmentIncluded — network discountIncluded — network discount
Whitening✓Included in cosmetic discountsLimited availability
Emergency visitSame-day at participating dentistsSame-day at participating dentists
Implants coveredYesYes
Ortho discountsYesYes
Cosmetic discounts✓YesLimited
Best marketsNational (broad coverage)Northeast, Southeast metros
Best forPatients with a participating Dental Access dentistExisting Cigna customers, metro markets

The Bottom Line

Cigna’s individual membership is $96/year versus the listed $149/year Aetna option through 1Dental; check setup fees and current seller terms. The published 262,000+ locations and ~110,000 dentists are not comparable network counts. Choose based on your dentist’s participation and written cash/member quotes, rather than assuming a larger network or lower treatment cost.

Choose Aetna Dental Savings if

Your dentist accepts the exact 1Dental Dental Access membership and its quoted member prices make the first-year fee worthwhile. Confirm participation and the $30 setup fee; do not infer local choice from a national provider-location count.

Choose Cigna Dental Savings if

Your dentist accepts Cigna Dental Savings and the written member quote justifies the annual fee. Its published savings range is 15–40%, with regional and procedure differences. An existing Cigna insurance policy does not establish shared billing or better value for this separate membership.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to have Aetna or Cigna insurance to use their savings plans?▼
No existing insurance policy is needed to buy these separate discount memberships. The Aetna-linked offer is 1Dental Dental Access, not carrier-direct Aetna Vital Savings. Check the seller’s eligibility and insurance-use terms for the exact membership before paying.
Are Aetna and Cigna savings plans actual insurance?▼
No. These are membership discount plans, not insurance. Aetna’s listed monthly tiers run up to $19.95/mo plus $30 setup. Cigna’s $8/mo individual equivalent is $96 paid annually in full, and its family equivalent is $11/mo on a $132 annual purchase. You pay the participating dentist’s member price directly; get a written quote.
Which covers more dental procedures?▼
Both plans cover the full range: cleanings, X-rays, fillings, root canals, extractions, crowns, bridges, dentures, implants, and orthodontics. Aetna extends discounts to some cosmetic procedures like teeth whitening; Cigna has more limited cosmetic coverage. Neither plan sets a dollar limit on how much dental work you can discount in a year, unlike insurance.
Can I stack these with dental insurance?▼
Do not assume the discounts apply to an insurance balance. Ask the seller and dentist whether the exact membership permits use with your insurance and how they would bill the treatment. Carrier-direct Aetna Vital Savings says it is not intended for people already covered by dental insurance; that is a separate product from the linked 1Dental Dental Access offer.
How do I find out if my dentist is in-network?▼
Both Aetna and Cigna have provider locator tools on their websites. Search by zip code and dentist name, or browse participating dentists near you. You can also call your dentist's office directly and ask if they accept Aetna Dental Access or Cigna DPPO savings plans — front-desk staff usually know immediately since it affects their billing.
Is Aetna Dental Savings worth it?▼
Compare written cash and member quotes against the exact first-year membership and setup fees. The listed individual option is $14.95/month through 1Dental plus $30 setup, with a $149/year option also listed. As illustrative arithmetic only, 30% of a $900 cash quote is $270; that is not a promised dentist price or proof of how many visits will recover the fee.
Is Cigna Dental Savings worth it?▼
It depends on your dentist’s participation and written prices. The individual membership is $96/year paid in full ($8/mo equivalent), with a published 15–40% savings range. Compare cash and member quotes, including the annual fee; national network totals and an existing Cigna policy do not establish value at your dentist.
What is Aetna's dental savings price list?▼
The listed 15–50% range is not a nationwide dentist fee schedule. Applied to hypothetical cash prices, it gives $100–170 for a $200 cleaning and $600–1,020 for a $1,200 crown, before membership and setup fees. These are illustrative calculations, not promised prices. Get written cash and member quotes under the exact Dental Access membership before treatment.
Is Cigna Dental Savings overpriced?▼
Compare the $96 annual individual fee ($8/mo equivalent, paid annually) with the exact competing membership’s billing and setup fees. Then compare written cash/member quotes from your dentist. The published ~110,000-dentist count does not establish local availability or a smaller network than a count of provider locations.
What if my dentist doesn't take Aetna or Cigna?▼
Then that plan won't help you at that office, no matter how good the discount percentage looks on paper. Search both provider locators for your specific dentist before choosing — if neither carries them, look at a broader network like Careington, or ask your dentist directly which discount plans they do accept. Some independent dentists take multiple networks even if they're not listed prominently online.
Can I cancel Aetna or Cigna Dental Savings anytime?▼
Check the cancellation and refund terms for the exact Aetna membership and billing option. Cigna requires its annual fee paid in full at purchase; it is not month-to-month. Changing a Cigna membership category requires canceling the existing membership and re-enrolling for a new 12-month term.
Which is better for a family — Aetna or Cigna?▼
The listed Aetna family option through 1Dental is $19.95/mo plus $30 setup; Cigna’s family membership is $132/year paid annually ($11/mo equivalent). Cigna includes a spouse or partner and dependents through age 17. Compare eligibility, first-year fees and each family member’s dentist; unlike published network counts do not decide the choice.
Does Aetna or Cigna cover a root canal?▼
Both advertise root-canal discounts at participating dentists, within published ranges of 15–50% for Aetna and 15–40% for Cigna. As illustrative arithmetic, 30% of a $700–1,500 cash quote is $210–450 before membership fees. Get written cash and member quotes for the tooth and procedure; these figures are not promised savings.
What happens if I move to a different state?▼
Confirm participation under the exact membership at your new dentist before treatment. The national catalog counts use different units and dates and do not establish which plan offers more usable dentists in your new city.
Can I add my spouse or kids to my plan later?▼
Cigna’s family category costs $132/year paid annually ($11/mo equivalent) and includes a spouse or partner and dependents through age 17. A category change requires canceling and re-enrolling for a new 12-month term. For the listed $19.95/mo Aetna family option through 1Dental, check the seller’s change, setup-fee and eligibility terms before adding anyone.
Is there a waiting period for crowns or major work?▼
No. Neither Aetna nor Cigna imposes a waiting period for any procedure, including crowns, root canals, dentures, or implants — a major difference from traditional dental insurance, which often makes you wait 6–12 months before covering major work. Activation is estimated at 3 business days; confirm the exact membership is active before treatment and you can book a major procedure the moment your membership is active.
What if my dentist drops out of the Aetna or Cigna network?▼
Confirm the membership remains active and use the exact plan’s locator to find a participating dentist. Unlike national counts of provider locations and dentists do not establish the availability of a replacement near you.
Can I cancel mid-year and get a refund?▼
Cigna’s current FAQ states a full refund within 30 days, then a refund prorated for the remaining term on request to customer service. Its annual fee is paid in full at purchase; this is not monthly billing. Check cancellation and refund terms for the exact Aetna membership sold by 1Dental separately.
Does Aetna or Cigna cover dentures or partials?▼
Yes — both plans discount full and partial dentures at participating dentists within their published ranges (15–50% for Aetna, 15–40% for Cigna). Dentures typically run $1,000–3,000 for a full set depending on materials, so a 25–30% discount can mean $250–900 in real savings, a meaningful amount for a procedure insurance annual maximums rarely cover in full.
Can I use Aetna or Cigna for a same-day emergency visit?▼
Many participating dentists in both networks accommodate same-day or next-day emergency visits, but availability depends on the individual office, not the plan itself. Call ahead and mention you have an Aetna Dental Access or Cigna DPPO savings membership — most front desks can tell you within minutes whether they can fit you in and confirm the discounted rate applies to emergency treatment.
Do Aetna or Cigna dental savings plans expire if I don't use them?▼
The membership stays active for the term you purchased regardless of visits. Cigna’s term is annual and paid in full; check the exact Aetna seller option’s term and renewal rules separately. Unused discounts are not a dollar balance that rolls over.
How much would a family of four actually save with Aetna vs Cigna over a year?▼
The listed Aetna family option through 1Dental costs $19.95/mo plus $30 setup; Cigna’s eligible family membership costs $132/year paid annually ($11/mo equivalent). These are not nearly identical fees. As illustrative arithmetic only, a hypothetical $1,200 cash total discounted 25–40% would save $300–480 before membership fees. Actual family savings require written cash and member quotes and eligibility checks.
Do Aetna or Cigna savings plans cover teeth whitening?▼
Aetna explicitly extends discounts to cosmetic procedures including whitening; Cigna's cosmetic coverage is more limited and may not include whitening at every participating office. If whitening matters to you specifically, confirm with your chosen dentist under either plan before assuming it's covered — cosmetic discount depth varies more by individual office than routine and major work does.

Not Sure Which Plan Fits Your Situation?

Our advisor matches you with the best dental savings plan based on your dentist, budget, and what dental work you need.

Talk to the Advisor →