One state, two very different markets: dense Chicagoland and wide-open downstate. Plan prices ignore both, so this page ranks the same five national memberships and explains where city and small-town buyers should actually differ in how they choose.
Careington 500 Series is the best dental savings plan for most Illinoisans: $12.95/mo ($129/yr plus a one-time $20 fee), one of the largest U.S. dentist networks, no waiting periods, 20–60% off covered procedures. Cheapest: Humana at $6.99/mo. Largest published network: Aetna at 262,000+ locations nationwide. All prices are national; verify your dentist by ZIP before enrolling.
Same plans and prices nationwide. Ranking reflects value for most buyers: price, network usefulness, and savings depth.
| # | Plan | From / mo | Network |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Careington 500 SeriesBest Overall | $12.95/mo($129/yr) | One of the largest in the U.S. |
| 2 | Humana Dental SavingsBest for Seniors | $6.99/mo | 135,000+ |
| 3 | 1DentalBest for Families | $14.58/mo($175/yr) | Careington network, one of the largest in the U.S. |
| 4 | Aetna Dental SavingsLargest Network | $7.99/mo($75/yr) | 262,000+ |
| 5 | Cigna Dental SavingsBest Transparency | $8/mo($96/yr) | ~110,000 |
Network counts above are national figures published by the carriers. None of them publish an Illinois-only dentist count, so run each plan's ZIP search before you commit.
Answer a few quick questions and we'll match you across our reviewed plans. Free. No email required to start or see results.
Not the pricing. None of the five reviewed plans sells an Illinois product, fee schedule, or rate; all five bill nationally whether your address is Wicker Park or Quincy. What Illinois changes is how much network depth matters to you personally. Chicagoland's density tends to mean plenty of participating offices within a short trip across the large networks, while many downstate counties have fewer dentists total, so any given plan's panel feels tighter.
That split maps cleanly onto two picks. City dwellers who value maximum choice fit Aetna's profile: 262,000+ provider locations nationally at $7.99/month ($75/year), family coverage at $10.99/month. Everyone else, especially buyers outside the metro core, starts with Careington's breadth and record back to 1979, then confirms access with a ZIP search rather than trusting the label.
Whichever way you lean, keep the verification mechanical: search your ZIP code in each plan's dentist directory on the enrollment site before paying anything, check your second-choice plan if your current dentist is missing, then call the office to confirm it honors the member fee schedule for your procedure code.
The catch deserves plain language: these plans lower bills instead of paying them, so no annual maximum protects you because no insurer exists behind the card. Discounts vary by procedure and office too. For most cash-paying Illinoisans that trade still beats insurance's waits and caps, as long as a participating dentist actually practices near you.
We publish audited national ranges instead of invented Illinois fee schedules. Metro offices routinely price above these figures; small-town practices below them. Ask any office for the plan's member rate before you book.
| Procedure | Typical retail | Typical with a plan |
|---|---|---|
| Composite filling | $200–$400 | $95–$145 (published Careington member price) |
| Single crown | $1,300 avg ($800–$2,500 range) | $520–$1,040 after a 20–60% discount |
| Routine cleanings and exams | Varies by office | Discounted the same way under every plan listed |
Filling numbers per our filling cost breakdown and filling cost without insurance. Crown numbers per our crown cost breakdown.
Want the short version? Our free advisor matches you across all seven reviewed plans in about a minute, or read our Illinois statewide guide for more depth.
For most uninsured Illinoisans, Careington 500 Series at $12.95/month ($129/year plus a one-time $20 sign-up fee) is the best dental savings plan. It pairs one of the largest U.S. networks with an operating record back to 1979. Humana at $6.99/month is the budget pick, choice-driven city buyers fit Aetna's 262,000+ locations, and families save with 1Dental's household tier.
Prices are identical across state lines, so treat this as a ZIP-code decision: the best plan in Illinois is the cheapest one that includes a dentist you can actually reach.
Not among the plans we review. All five are national discount memberships sold at the same price in Illinois as elsewhere. Any page advertising special Prairie State pricing made it up.
Participation varies office by office and no carrier publishes counts for Chicago, Springfield, Peoria, or any other Illinois market. Search the plan's dentist directory by ZIP before enrolling, or call the office and ask whether they accept the plan by name.
No. They are discount memberships: no claims, no deductibles, no waiting periods, no annual maximums. You pay the discounted fee directly to the participating dentist at each appointment.
Yes. Once insurance hits its annual maximum, the plan discounts additional work beyond the cap, which matters for crowns and root canal work. Coordinate with the billing office before treatment.
Most activate in about 3 business days with no waiting period for any procedure. If you need a filling or crown now, the member discount applies to that first appointment.