Careington and Humana are both strong dental savings plans, but they're built for slightly different audiences. Careington's 500 Series is the best general-purpose plan — lowest price ($8.95/mo individual), largest network, and ideal for families. Humana's dental savings plan is one of the best options for seniors: it's Medicare-friendly, well-suited for dentures and restorative work, and backed by one of the largest dental networks in the country (350,000+ providers). For anyone under 60 without a strong reason to prefer Humana, Careington usually wins on price and simplicity. For seniors or anyone on Medicare, Humana is worth a serious look.
The most widely-used dental discount network
★★★★☆4.4From $8.95/mo · 200,000+ network dentists
Medicare-friendly dental savings with competitive pricing
★★★★☆4.0From $9/mo · 350,000+ network dentists
| Feature | Careington 500 Series | Humana Dental Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Individual/month | ✓$8.95/mo | $9–14/mo |
| Family/month | ✓$13.95/mo | $18–25/mo |
| Network size | 200,000+ dentists | ✓350,000+ dentists |
| Typical savings | ✓20–60% | 15–50% |
| Activation time | 3 business days | 3 business days |
| Waiting period | None | None |
| Annual maximum | None | None |
| Ortho discounts | ✓Yes | No |
| Implants | Yes — deep discounts | Yes |
| Dentures | Yes | ✓Yes — strong senior pricing |
| Medicare-friendly | Not specifically | ✓Yes — Medicare supplement option |
| Best for | Families, individuals, all ages | Seniors, Medicare gap coverage |
Careington wins on price, savings rate, and ortho discounts; Humana wins on network size and senior/Medicare suitability.
You're under 60, want the lowest monthly price ($8.95 individual, $13.95 family), need orthodontic discounts, or want higher savings percentages (up to 60%). Careington is the best all-around value for most families and individuals who just want reliable discounts at a broad network of dentists.
You're a senior looking for Medicare supplement dental coverage, need a plan with strong denture and restorative pricing, or want the largest possible provider network (350,000+ dentists). Humana's plan is specifically tuned for older adults — competitive pricing for the 65+ demographic where dental insurance is often unavailable or unaffordable.
Our 2-minute quiz matches you with the best dental savings plan based on your dentist, budget, and what dental work you need.
Take the Free Quiz →This comparison is independent. We may earn a commission if you enroll through our links — at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.